Equilibration of the populations in each well: §9.2, (9.2.1)–(9.2.33), (9.2.46)–(9.2.49) #
Kramers' method reduces the double-well Smoluchowski equation to the three relaxation equations
(9.2.8) for the well populations N_a, N_c and the barrier population N₀. We formalise:
flux_identity— (9.2.5):U'p + Dp' = D p_s ∂ₓ(p/p_s)forp_s ∝ e^{-U/D}, andkramers_integrated— (9.2.6), its integral (exact);kramers_ansatz— (9.2.7) ⇒ (9.2.8) (the ansatz is a named hypothesis);barrier_population— (9.2.13), corrected (N₀ = n₀[μN_a/n_a + κN_c/n_c]/(κ + μ));barrier_population_printed_wrong;threeState_stationary— (9.2.14), corrected (`Ṅ₀ = D{N_a/(n_aκ) + N_c/(n_cμ)- N₀ n₀⁻¹(κ⁻¹ + μ⁻¹)}
): adiabatic elimination ofN₀` gives back (9.2.13);
- N₀ n₀⁻¹(κ⁻¹ + μ⁻¹)}
relaxation_rates— (9.2.16)–(9.2.18), corrected sign (Ṅ_a = -r_aN_a + r_cN_c),τ_r⁻¹ = r_a + r_c = D/(n_a n_c ∫_a^c p_s⁻¹);escape_time— (9.2.19)–(9.2.20): the mean of the exponential decay law isn_aκ/D;- chymotrypsinogen §9.2.2:
chymo_extremum— (9.2.30)–(9.2.31), exact for locally quadraticU₀;chymo_population_ratio— (9.2.32) (printed with the label (9.3.32));chymo_H_ratio,chymo_relaxTime— (9.2.33) with the corrections recorded below; discrete_ansatz_M— (9.2.46)–(9.2.49) with the corrected ranges ofψ.
Errata recorded.
(9.2.4) n_a = ∫_{-∞}^b p_s (not ∫^c). (9.2.13) N_a, N_c must be divided by n_a, n_c.
(9.2.14) the coefficient of N₀ is D n₀⁻¹(κ⁻¹ + μ⁻¹) (and N₀ enters as N₀/n₀).
(9.2.16) Ṅ_a = -r_a N_a + r_c N_c. (9.3.32) is (9.2.32). (9.2.33) for (9.2.26) the effective
potential is U/γ and D = kT/γ, so H carries a factor γ (not γ⁻¹) and the factor
(β_aβ_c)^{1/4}; with τ_r(0) = πH(0) the second line needs 2τ_r(0) in place of τ_r(0).
(9.2.49) ψ(z) = n_a⁻¹ Σ_{y=z}^{b-1} P_s(y) for z ≤ b and n_c⁻¹ Σ_{y=b}^{z-1} P_s(y) for
z > b (the text has upper limits b and z + 1).
(9.2.5)–(9.2.6) #
(9.2.5): with p_s = 𝒩 e^{-U/D}, the probability current of (9.1.1) is
U'p + Dp' = D p_s ∂ₓ(p/p_s).
(9.2.6), exact: ∫_a^{x₀} (U'p + Dp')/p_s = D[p(x₀)/p_s(x₀) - p(a)/p_s(a)].
(9.2.7)–(9.2.18): the three relaxation equations #
(9.2.7) ⇒ (9.2.8). Under Kramers' ansatz, expressed as the named hypothesis that
∫_a^{x₀} M/p_s = N_a κ(x₀) with p(a)/p_s(a) = N_a/n_a and p(x₀)/p_s(x₀) = N₀/n₀, the exact
identity (9.2.6) (whose time derivative gives d_t ∫ M/p_s) becomes
κ Ṅ_a = D[N₀/n₀ - N_a/n_a].
(9.2.13), corrected. If κṄ_a = D[N₀/n₀ - N_a/n_a], μṄ_c = D[N₀/n₀ - N_c/n_c] and
Ṅ_a = -Ṅ_c, then N₀ = n₀[μN_a/n_a + κN_c/n_c]/(κ + μ).
Erratum (9.2.13). The printed N₀ = n₀[μN_a + κN_c]/(κ + μ) is not a consequence of
(9.2.8): with κ = μ = D = n₀ = 1, n_a = 1/4, n_c = 3/4, N_a = N_c = 1/2 the equations
(9.2.8) force N₀ = 4/3, not 1/2.
(9.2.14), corrected. The intermediate-state equation
Ṅ₀ = D{N_a/(n_aκ) + N_c/(n_cμ) - (N₀/n₀)(κ⁻¹ + μ⁻¹)} has, as its adiabatic (Ṅ₀ = 0)
solution, exactly (9.2.13).
(9.2.16)–(9.2.18), corrected sign. Eliminating N₀ from (9.2.8):
Ṅ_a = -r_a N_a + r_c N_c with r_a = D/(n_a I), r_c = D/(n_c I), I = κ + μ = ∫_a^c p_s⁻¹,
and (for n_a + n_c = 1) r_a + r_c = D/(n_a n_c I).
§9.2.2: reversible denaturation of chymotrypsinogen #
(9.2.30)–(9.2.31), exact for a locally quadratic U₀. If U₀(x) = U₀(a) + k/2 (x-a)²
near a (k = U₀''(a) ≠ 0), then U = U₀ + xδp is stationary at a + βδp, β = -1/k, with
value U₀(a) + aδp + ½βδp². (The same computation applies at b, with k = U₀''(b) < 0 and
β_b = -1/U₀''(b) > 0, and at c.)
(9.2.32) (printed with the label (9.3.32)). With U(x) = U₀(x) + xδp, quadratic
extrema (9.2.31) and the balance condition (9.2.29) √k_a e^{U₀(a)/kT} = √k_c e^{U₀(c)/kT},
the ratio (9.2.23) √(k_c/k_a) e^{[U(c) - U(a)]/kT} equals
exp[-(a - c)δp/kT - (β_a - β_c)δp²/(2kT)].
The factor H of (9.2.25) for the chymotrypsinogen model (9.2.26), whose effective
potential is U/γ and effective diffusion kT/γ: H = γ k_b^{-1/2}(k_a k_c)^{-1/4} e^{[2U(b) - U(a) - U(c)]/(2kT)} (curvatures k = |U''|).
Equations
- Gardiner.Escape.chymoH γ ka kb kc Ua Ub Uc kT = Gardiner.Escape.Hfac (ka / γ) (kb / γ) (kc / γ) (Ua / γ) (Ub / γ) (Uc / γ) (kT / γ)
Instances For
(9.2.33), corrected. With the extrema shifted by (9.2.31) and curvatures unchanged
(locally quadratic U₀), H(δp) = H(0) exp[-(a + c - 2b)δp/(2kT) + (β_b - ½β_a - ½β_c)δp²/(2kT)],
and H(0) = γ β_b^{1/2}(β_aβ_c)^{1/4} e^{[2U₀(b) - U₀(a) - U₀(c)]/(2kT)} (β_a = -1/k_a,
β_c = -1/k_c, β_b = 1/k_b).
(9.2.33), first line, corrected. At δp = 0 (n_a = n_c = ½) the relaxation time
(9.2.24) is τ_r(0) = 2πH(0)·½ = πH(0), H(0) = γ β_b^{1/2}(β_aβ_c)^{1/4}e^{[2U(b)-U(a)-U(c)]/2kT}
in terms of β_b = 1/k_b, β_aβ_c = 1/(k_ak_c).
(9.2.46)–(9.2.49): the discrete ansatz #
(9.2.46) ⇒ the corrected (9.2.49). If P(y) = P_s(y) N_a/n_a for y < b with
n_a = Σ_{y<b} P_s(y), then for z ≤ b, M(z) = Σ_{y<z} P(y) = N_a[1 - ψ(z)] with
ψ(z) = n_a⁻¹ Σ_{y=z}^{b-1} P_s(y) (upper limit b - 1, not b).
Instances: the mean escape time (9.2.20) for D = 1, n_a = ½, κ = 3 is 3/2; for
κ = 1, μ = 2, D = n₀ = 1, n_a = ¼, n_c = ¾, N_a = N_c = ½, the relaxation equations
(9.2.8) force N₀ = 14/9 (9.2.13 corrected) and Ṅ_a = -4/9 = -r_aN_a + r_cN_c (9.2.16).